Test Water Before Drilling to Protect Your Valuable Asset;
Doesn’t Matter If You’re Pro or Anti Drilling;
What to Expect from Professional Water Testing
Among the saddest regrets for property owners who believe their water is contaminated by gas drilling: They didn’t test their water before drilling began.
As reported last year by National Geographic News:
“Because [property owners] did not test their water for chemicals before drilling began, they have no baseline against which to compare any current readings. … That omission is important….”1
Whether property owners embrace drilling or not, anyone who expects drilling in their community should have their water professionally tested using a certified analytical laboratory. For most citizens, their property is the single most valuable asset they possess. No surprise – contaminated water impacts property value, use and the ability to sell that property.
What to Expect
Testing your ground and surface water is not a do-it-yourself project. The legal admissibility of your test results depends on a strict protocol.
Downstream Strategies is a multi-disciplinary, environmental consulting company based in Morgantown, WVA. Its range of services includes policy analysis, field monitoring, expert testimony and litigation support, scientific research and more. Link: http://www.downstreamstrategies.com/index.html
Evan Hansen, President, and Nathan Askins, Environmental Analyst, shared their guidance on what landowners should expect when considering professional monitoring and testing of water on their property. The following is based on Downstream Strategies’ current practice and protocol.
Define Scope of Work
The water monitoring and testing service begins with defining the scope of the work with the property owner. Does the property owner want only well water tested, or does he/she want all surface water (ponds and streams) as well as ground water (well water) tested?
What to Test For
Next, what do you want to test for? As more is learned about chemicals used in drilling for shale gas, the potential test list grows longer. Property owners should always look for the latest, updated water test recommendations if shale gas drilling is moving into the neighborhood.
Current recommendations include testing for pH, conductivity, total dissolved solids and arsenic to methane and BTEX chemicals (benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene) to radiation (gross alpha, gross beta and more). A detailed list follows in this post.
Attention to Detail
Regardless of the scope of work, the attention to detail and rigor is far beyond the skill and equipment of most do-it-yourselfers. For example:
- Certified labs require multiple containers for each area sampled (water well, ponds, stream, etc.). The lab provides the sampling containers. Some labs require five containers; some require as many as 18. In other words, if a property owner is testing two water wells, two ponds and a stream, that would equal five sample areas. To that would be added a “field blank” sample, which is a quality assurance/quality control measure. The required field blank containers would be filled with distilled, dionized water labeled and submitted to the lab along with the “real” samples. For a project based on five sample areas plus the field blank – and using a lab that requires 18 containers per sample area – that amounts to 108 containers. If the lab only requires five containers per sample area, that would be 30 containers.
- Certain sample containers require zero headspace between the fill of water to be tested and the inside lid of the container. In other words, no air space between the top of the water sample and the lid. This protocol applies to lab testing for methane and the BTEX chemicals.
- Downstream Strategies takes GPS (Global Positioning System) coordinates for each sampling area so the location of the sampling can be pinpointed.
Following is a current list of what a property owner should consider testing for:
Current recommended water testing parameters include:
pH, acidity, alkalinity, hardness, conductivity, total dissolved solids, iron, aluminum, manganese, calcium, sodium, sulfate, chloride, arsenic, barium, strontium, lead, bromide.
Plus the following hydrocarbon-related parameters:
BTEX (benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, and xylene); total petroleum hydrocarbons (TPH) in the gas, oil and diesel ranges; acrylonitrile; and methane.
In addition, sample for radiation:
gross alpha, gross beta, radium-226, and radium-228
Depending on the size of the property and the areas to be sampled, the time spent on your property could range from 4 to 8 hours.
Cost will be driven by the scope of the work. For example, one recent professional monitoring and testing involved a property with more than 50 acres. The areas to be sampled included two ponds, two wells and a stream, and included a field blank. A significant amount of travel was required which added to the expense. Cost to the property owner in this case was about $7,000. About half of that total cost was for the certified lab tests.
If the water monitoring service is sampling a property that is relatively local (reducing travel and labor costs); and only one water well plus field blank is to be tested, the approximate cost would be about $3,200. If the property owner decides to eliminate the quality control/quality assurance of the field blank, and wanted only one water well tested, the cost would be about $2,500.
ShaleTest: Non-Profit Environmental Test Option
There are alternatives for landowners who find the cost of professional water monitoring and testing too high.
For example, ShaleTest is a non-profit organization founded last year by Tim Ruggiero and Calvin Tillman. Recently, it became affiliated with Earthworks. Link: http://www.shaletest.org/index.php
As it states on its website: Their sole purpose is “to conduct air, water and soil testing for affected people who could not afford the high costs of testing.”
Headquartered in the heart of the Barnett Shale near Fort Worth, Texas, ShaleTest is up and running in three states – Texas, Pennsylvania and Arkansas, according to Ruggiero. The organization is seeking to expand and is looking for volunteers, especially in Marcellus Shale states.
ShaleTest will use nationally certified laboratories with chain of custody certification. Among its advisors is Wilma Subra, a recipient of the MacArthur Foundation’s Fellowship “Genius Award” for helping citizens cope with and fight environmental issues in their communities.
2 In states like New York with the equivalent of eminent domain in the form of compulsory integration, property owners are not allowed to opt out of drilling activities. They will be compelled to be integrated into a drilling unit.
Independent testing of your water is a positive step you can take to protect your property value should something go wrong. Do not let the only water testing on your property be done by the gas industry.
Links & Resources
1 National Geographic News – Special Report, “A Dream Dashed by the Rush on Gas,” by Marianne Lavelle, October 17, 2010. The citation from the article is found in the 6th paragraph under the subhead, “Tracking the Source of the Pollution” at this link: http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2010/10/101022-energy-marcellus-shale-gas-environment/
Downstream Strategies – Check out the company’s range of services on its website. “Downstream Strategies offers environmental consulting services that combine sound interdisciplinary skills with a core belief in the importance of protecting the environment and linking economic development with natural resource stewardship.”
Website: http://www.downstreamstrategies.com/ Phone: 304-292-2450
ShaleTest – This organization springs from the Barnett Shale zone and was founded by Tim Ruggiero and Calvin Tillman, former mayor of DISH, Texas. It’s purpose, as the website states: “To provide environmental testing of private individuals drinking water, air and soil, for those affected or potentially affected by natural gas development whose personal financial situation prohibit the costs of test.” Website: http://shaletest.org/ Phone: 530-237-4558
2 Compulsory integration is the law in New York State. Like forced pooling, it is a variation of eminent domain which is legal theft of surface and/or subsurface property rights. Refer to the “Landowner Option Guide” on the NY Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) website. Note its warning to property owners in the fourth paragraph: http://www.dec.ny.gov/energy/1590.html
See also this previous post, Broken Lease Agreements (scroll down about midway through the post): http://www.spectraenergywatch.com/blog/?p=1175
NOTE: This article is cross-posted on the Accountability Central website at this link: http://www.accountability-central.com/nc/single-view-default/article/voices-from-the-shale-test-water-before-drilling-to-protect-your-valuable-asset/ Accountability Central is part of the Governance & Accountability Institute, Inc.